What Are Lactation Cookies — and Do They Actually Work?

If you've been up at 2am with a newborn, Googling how to increase your milk supply, you've probably come across lactation cookies. So what actually are they, what makes them different from a regular cookie, and do they work?

As a doula and postpartum nutrition consultant who also runs a lactation cookie bakery, I want to give you an honest picture: where these cookies come from, what the research can and can't tell us yet, and how they fit into the bigger picture of feeding your baby.

Text overlay on a striped background asking 'Do Lactation Cookies Actually Work?'

What makes a cookie a "lactation" cookie?

A lactation cookie is a cookie made for breastfeeding mums, with ingredients that have been part of postpartum food traditions for generations. You'll usually find some combination of these four:

Oats

A wholegrain staple in postpartum kitchens all over the world, and filling enough to keep you going between feeds.

Flaxseed

A source of omega-3 fats and fibre, and a common addition to breastfeeding recipes.

Brewer's yeast

A long-standing ingredient in breastfeeding recipes, with a savoury, slightly nutty flavour.

Fenugreek

Used in Ayurvedic and Middle Eastern cooking for centuries, and one of the best-known herbs in breastfeeding traditions.

Foods and herbs like these are called galactagogues (or lactogenic foods). Every Milk it cookie is built on all four.

Where the idea comes from

Feeding new mothers special foods is one of the oldest traditions there is. Across the world, the weeks after birth come with their own recipes, passed down from mothers and grandmothers:

IndiaLadoos made with fenugreek, ghee and sesame, given to new mums
Middle EastHalva made with tahini and spices, gifted to new mothers
KoreaMiyeok-guk (seaweed soup), eaten daily after birth
Western herbalismOats, brewer's yeast and fennel tea, used for generations

What these traditions share is the idea that a new mother should be fed, warmly and often, by the people around her. The same ingredients turn up again and again, in kitchens that never shared a recipe book. A lactation cookie is a modern, one-handed version of that wisdom.

Want to go further than cookies? Here are some foods for breastfeeding and milk supply, and how to work them into your day.

So, do lactation cookies actually work?

Very little research has been done on lactation foods and herbs, and the studies that do exist are small. The Academy of Breastfeeding Medicine says there isn't yet enough good-quality evidence to recommend any particular food or herb, which is a reflection of how little has been studied rather than proof either way. Breastfeeding research has never had much funding, and these are ingredients mums have trusted for a very long time.

Science hasn't caught up with tradition yet.

What we do know is that milk supply runs on supply and demand. How often, and how well, milk leaves your breasts does most of the work, so good food works best alongside frequent feeding and a comfortable latch, never instead of them. If you want to build your supply, here's how to increase breast milk supply naturally.

And feeding a baby is hungry work. Your energy needs go up while you're breastfeeding, and the early weeks are exactly when meals get skipped, lunch becomes toast crusts and you realise it's 3pm and you haven't eaten. Having something nourishing within reach of where you feed makes a real difference to how you feel. Lactation cookies are a lovely excuse to keep a stash by the sofa.

Three stacked Milk it Classic lactation cookies on a cream plate with brown polka dots against a blue tiled background

What cookies can't replace

Lactation cookies are food, not a medical treatment. They can't:

  • Fix a latch problem, tongue tie or a medical cause of low supply
  • Replace frequent feeding, skin-to-skin or skilled breastfeeding support
  • Bring in milk if you're not already producing it

If something doesn't feel right, speak to your midwife, health visitor or an IBCLC, or call the National Breastfeeding Helpline on 0300 100 0212. Our Breastfeeding Support Hub also has guidance and resources for every kind of feeding journey.

A note on fenugreek: check with your GP, pharmacist or an IBCLC first if you take medication (especially for diabetes or blood thinning) or have a peanut, chickpea or other legume allergy. Our cookies are for after baby arrives, not pregnancy.

Wait… do they contain breastmilk?

Nope! There's no breastmilk in our cookies (or any lactation cookies). It's a common mix-up, but the "lactation" refers to who they're made for. We're feeding you, not baking with breastmilk.

Why we make them

A box of cookies arriving on your doorstep, made just for you, is a small act of care at a time when most of the attention is on the baby. It's the same instinct behind every one of those traditions: look after the mother. Milk it cookies are:

  • Freshly baked in small batches every week
  • Made with oats, flaxseed, brewer's yeast and fenugreek, in proper bakery-style flavours, not cardboard health bars
  • Created by a doula, certified pregnancy and postpartum nutrition consultant and breastfeeding support counsellor
  • Sent with access to breastfeeding resources in every box

Made for the mother, because feeding a baby should never mean forgetting her.

★★★★★

"I'm on my third box and these cookies are honestly so delicious and such a welcome treat after a long day looking after a little one! … Feels like a real gift when they arrive in the post."

Alice P., verified buyer

Ready to try some for yourself?

Blue Milk it gift box with a cream ribbon on a brown shipping box on a blue and white checked bed

Freshly baked cookie box

Eight cookies, your choice of flavours, baked fresh and posted on our weekly bake day.

Order your box

Two pouches of Milk it frozen lactation cookie dough, Classic and Rich, on a silver tray

Frozen cookie dough

Same ingredients, straight from your freezer to the oven, so warm cookies are never far away.

Shop frozen dough

Or explore all our cookie flavours.

Want to dig into the sources?

Mel Mckechnie, doula and pregnancy and postpartum nutrition consultant

Written by Mel Mckechnie: doula and pregnancy & postpartum nutrition consultant

This post is for general information and isn't a substitute for personalised advice from your midwife, health visitor, GP or a lactation consultant.

0 comments

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

Get the Cookies & the Context

Want fresh content for new motherhood (and fresh cookie drop reminders) in your inbox? Sign up for 10% off your first freshly baked cookies box and blog updates that actually support you in this season.